Serving Milwaukee, WI and the Surrounding Areas

5354 S. 27th | Milwaukee, WI

Benny's Cafe Logo

Open 7 days a week 7AM-9PM

Now Open for Dine-IN

SINCE 2005

Complement any meal at Benny's Café with a tasty soup - they're made from scratch daily! It's something we've been known for since 2005.


We also invite you to stop in for our fish fry every Friday. It's a day when fish is the main ingredient on our menu and you'll have your choice of additional fish specials.


If you're looking to feed a bigger group, our buckets of chicken or fish are perfect choices. Call 414-431-0004 ahead of time and pick up your buckets at our convenient drive-up window.

Mouthwatering soups, chicken, and fish

"Exceptional food (Benny's special chicken is the bomb diggity), and attentive and friendly staff.

- George B., Google review

Breakfast, lunch, and dinner menus are available for call-ahead carryout.


Visit Benny's Café at

5354 S 27th St.

Milwaukee, WI 53221

Carry Out

Fish Fry

8 Pieces


12 Pieces


16 Pieces


20 Pieces


24 Pieces


Broasted Chicken

8 Pieces


12 Pieces


16 Pieces


20 Pieces


24 Pieces


Add $0.35 for all to go orders


ATM Available

Homemade Soup







Soup Chicken bucket

Fish Fry and Broasted Chicken Carry Out Includes French Fries, Coleslaw & Bread